GIS Mapping, Education and Research
Home   Store   Free GIS   Education   Free Shapefiles   Census   Weather   Energy   Climate Change   News   Maps   TOPO   Aerial   GPS   Learn GIS

DOWNLOAD SHAPEFILES: Canada FSA Postal - Zip Code - U.S. Waterbodies & Wetlands - Geographic Names - School Districts - Indian Federal Lands
Zip Code/Demographics - Climate Change - U.S. Streams, Rivers & Waterways - Tornadoes - Nuclear Facilities - Dams & Risk - 2013 Toxic Release Inventory TRI

GIS Shapefile Store - for Beginners & Experienced GIS Users Alike. Geographic Names Information System, Nuclear Facilities, Zip Code Boundaries, School Districts, Indian & Federal Lands, Climate Change, Tornadoes, Dams - Create digital GIS maps in minutes.

Toxic Release Inventory TRI Shapefiles

Canada FSA Postal Code Shapefile

GNIS Shapefiles 2,000,000+ Points

Nuclear Energy Facilities in the U.S.

Download Zip Code with Demographics Shapefiles

Download U.S. Streams & Rivers Shapefiles

Download Water Body & Wetland Shapefiles

Download Zip Code Boundary Shapefiles

Download School District Shapefiles

Download Indian & Federal Land Shapefiles

Download Climate Change Shapefiles

Download Tornado Shapefiles

Download Dams & Risks Shapefiles

Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter

Didn't find what you are looking for? Email me and I'll find it for you.

Progressive Links

Federation of American Scientists

Physicians for Social Responsibility

Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility

Union of Concerned Scientists


Reader Supported News

Common Dreams


Huffington Post

Media Matters

Think Progress

Grist Environmental News

Climate Shift Blog

MapCruzin Consulting
Data Research and GIS Specialists.

GIS Tutorials

GIS Basics

GIS Terminology

Of Interest

Arctic National Wildlife Refuge Maps

Climate Shift - The effects of climate shift on the future of planet earth and its inhabitants.

Right to Know or Left to Wonder?

Hazardscapes - Toxic and Nuclear Risks in your backyard.

War & Environment

Worst Case Scenarios: Terrorism & industrial chemicals.

GAO says Toxic Chemical Review Process Faulted: Scientists on EPA Advisory Panels Often Have Conflicts of Interest
Fair Use Statement


<-- Return To Right-To-Know or Left-To-Wonder?

Download the GAO Report, "EPA's Science Advisory Board Panels: Improved Policies and Procedures Needed to Ensure Independence and Balance" PDF format (right click recommended) or Text formats.

Source: Washington Post

Toxic Chemical Review Process Faulted
Scientists on EPA Advisory Panels Often Have Conflicts of Interest, GAO Says

By Eric Pianin
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, July 16, 2001; Page A02

Scientists and experts who advise the Environmental Protection Agency on a broad range of regulations governing toxic chemicals and air and water quality frequently have ties to the affected industries or other conflicts of interest, according to a new government study.


The General Accounting Office report found serious deficiencies in the EPA's procedures for preventing conflicts of interest and ensuring a proper balance of views among members of Science Advisory Board panels.

For example, four of the 13 panel members who studied the cancer risks of the toxic chemical 1,3-butadiene in 1998 had worked for chemical companies or industry-affiliated research organizations -- including one who had worked for a company that manufactured 1,3-butadiene, according to the report.

The GAO found similar problems on three other cancer-risk assessment panels in recent years. In one case, seven of 17 advisory board members worked for chemical companies or for industry-affiliated research organizations. Five other panelists had received consulting or other fees from chemical manufacturers.

"The regulatory process benefits from scientific and technical knowledge, expertise and competencies of panel members," the report stated. "However, the work of fully competent peer review panels can be undermined by allegations of conflict of interest and bias."

The study, requested by Rep. Henry A. Waxman (Calif.), ranking Democrat on the House Government Reform Committee, is scheduled to be released today. The GAO review comes at a time of growing concern about industry's influence over government rule- making and regulations.

"The American people expect decisions that affect environmental and public health regulations to be based on unbiased science," Waxman said, "but this GAO study reveals polluting industries are in a position to influence panel findings."

The director of the EPA's Science Advisory Board staff "generally agreed with the report's findings and recommendations" and pledged to improve operations and procedures, according to the GAO report. A spokesman for EPA Administrator Christine Todd Whitman said late Friday she had not seen the report and declined to comment.


The Science Advisory Board was established by Congress in 1978 to provide independent scientific and engineering advice to EPA administrators on the technical basis for EPA regulations. The board often convenes peer review panels to assess the scientific and technical rationales underlying current or proposed EPA regulations and policies.

By law, the panels must be "fairly balanced" in terms of the points of view represented, and the advice should reflect members' independent judgment, without improper influences from special interests.

Earlier this year, Greenpeace and the Center for Health, Environment and Justice, two environmental groups, complained about the makeup of a subcommittee of an EPA scientific advisory panel assessing the health threats of the chemical dioxin. About one-third of the 21 panel members were scientists and scholars who have worked as paid consultants to the chemical industry.

According to the GAO report, EPA officials have failed to provide for adequate determinations of conflicts of interest when panels are formed and do not obtain sufficient information to evaluate conflicts of interest. The report said the EPA also fails to obtain appropriate information on financial disclosure forms, fails to review disclosure forms in a timely fashion and fails to adequately disclose potential conflicts of interest to the public.

Although the GAO did not assess whether the makeup of the panels affected the deliberations, the 1,3-butadiene panel recommended downgrading the significance of exposure to the synthetic chemical compound that is used in manufacturing synthetic rubber and nylon.

Based on studies that show high rates of leukemia in exposed workers, an EPA senior staff scientist had recommended that 1,3- butadiene be classified as a "known" human carcinogen. Although the panel did not reach a consensus, a majority of the panelists recommended that the chemical be classified as a "probable" human carcinogen.

A federal financial conflict-of-interest statute prohibits federal employees from acting personally and substantially in any "particular matter" that has a direct and predictable effect on their financial interests. However, an exemption allows special government employees serving on advisory panels to participate in matters that directly affect their employer's financial interest if the employer is not "singularly affected."

Routt Reigart, professor of pediatrics at the Medical University of South Carolina and a former member of a scientific advisory panel that evaluated the use of data from human experimentation, said he was troubled that some members had conflicts of interest that were not readily known. "There is not a tight method of disclosing conflicts of interest," Reigart said.

Erik Olson of the Natural Resources Defense Council, an environmental group, said that what "we're seeing is advisory board panels -- stacked with industry mouthpieces -- acting like kangaroo courts to strike down important EPA initiatives."

2001 The Washington Post Company

<-- Return To Right-To-Know or Left-To-Wonder?

Didn't find what you are looking for? We've been online since 1996 and have created 1000's of pages. Search below and you may find just what you are looking for.

Michael R. Meuser
Data Research & GIS Specialist is an independent firm specializing in GIS project development and data research. We created the first U.S. based interactive toxic chemical facility maps on the internet in 1996 and we have been online ever since. Learn more about us and our services.

Have a project in mind? If you have data, GIS project or custom shapefile needs contact Mike.

Contact Us

Report Broken Links

Subscribe for Updates

Follow on Facebook
News & Updates

Find: Maps, Shapefiles, GIS Software & More

MapCruzin Blog for updates, questions and answers
Blog Updates

More Blog Updates


Google Earth Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) Maps
Lester Brown's Plan B 3.0
State GIS Shapefiles, Maps & Resources
GIS Shapefiles & Maps
GIS Programs, Tools & Resources
Free World Country & Regional Maps
GIS / GPS Careers and Job Positions
Disease Outbreak Maps
Extreme Weather & Disaster Maps
Free World Maps from the CIA Factbook
Arctic National Wildlife Refuge ANWR Maps
Oil and Gas Maps
Africanized Honey Bees
Renewable Energy Potential Maps of the United States
Terrorism Maps
War Maps
Google Maps
Weather Maps
GPS Resources
Historical Maps of the World
Google Earth
Library of Congress American Memory Map Downloads
Toxic Chemical Pollution Maps
Climate Change Maps
Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) Maps
Census Shapefiles
World Maps


Environmental Justice
Data Sources
Greenwash & JunkScience
Statistical Resources
Wireless Dangers
Surviving Climate Change
Global Right-To-Know
Creating Living Economies
Books of Note
Toxic Klamath River
Federal Lands Maps
TRI Analysis
TRI Webmaps
EnviroRisk Map Network
Community-Based Research
Right-To-Know or Left to Wonder?
Chemical Industry Archives
21st Century Warfare
National Parks and Public Lands
Trade Secrets/Toxic Deception
GIS Books
Our Projects
Other Projects
1999 Archive Environews
Environmental Books
Environmental Links
Redwood Coast Information
Recycle, Salvage, Reuse

Shapefile Store
Free GIS Software
Free Map Downloads
Free Shapefiles
Free Remote Sensing
Free Topo Maps
Free GIS Tutorial
Free GPS

About MapCruzin - Cookies, Privacy, Fair Use and Disclaimer - Advertise on

Copyright © 1996 - 2019 Michael Meuser, All Rights Reserved
MapCruzin is a Pop-Up Free Website -- Best Viewed With ANY Browser