reimagining relationships
Home   Store   Free GIS   Education   Free Shapefiles   Census   Weather   Energy   Climate Change   News   Maps   TOPO   Aerial   GPS   Learn GIS

DOWNLOAD SHAPEFILES: Canada FSA Postal - Zip Code - U.S. Waterbodies & Wetlands - Geographic Names - School Districts - Indian Federal Lands
Zip Code/Demographics - Climate Change - U.S. Streams, Rivers & Waterways - Tornadoes - Nuclear Facilities - Dams & Risk - 2013 Toxic Release Inventory TRI

ANWR Arctic National Wildlife Refuge; What is at stake; removed USFWS website; photos, maps, descriptions

tools for survival plans Maps Food Water Health Gardening Energy Housing Security Communications Livelihood

Money Making Tips Work from Home Make Money Used Lumber & Building Materal Beginner's Guide Buy/Sell Gold Electronics & Computer

GIS Shapefile Store - for Beginners & Experienced GIS Users Alike. Geographic Names Information System, Nuclear Facilities, Zip Code Boundaries, School Districts, Indian & Federal Lands, Climate Change, Tornadoes, Dams - Create digital GIS maps in minutes.

Toxic Release Inventory TRI Shapefiles

Canada FSA Postal Code Shapefile

GNIS Shapefiles 2,000,000+ Points

Nuclear Energy Facilities in the U.S.

Download Zip Code with Demographics Shapefiles

Download U.S. Streams & Rivers Shapefiles

Download Water Body & Wetland Shapefiles

Download Zip Code Boundary Shapefiles

Download School District Shapefiles

Download Indian & Federal Land Shapefiles

Download Climate Change Shapefiles

Download Tornado Shapefiles

Download Dams & Risks Shapefiles

Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter

Didn't find what you are looking for? Email me and I'll find it for you.

Progressive Links

Federation of American Scientists

Physicians for Social Responsibility

Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility

Union of Concerned Scientists


Reader Supported News

Common Dreams


Huffington Post

Media Matters

Think Progress

Grist Environmental News

Climate Shift Blog

MapCruzin Consulting
Data Research and GIS Specialists.

GIS Tutorials

GIS Basics

GIS Terminology

Of Interest

Arctic National Wildlife Refuge Maps

Climate Shift - The effects of climate shift on the future of planet earth and its inhabitants.

Right to Know or Left to Wonder?

Hazardscapes - Toxic and Nuclear Risks in your backyard.

War & Environment

Worst Case Scenarios: Terrorism & industrial chemicals.

REVIEW - The Culture of Denial: Why the Environmental Movement Needs a Strategy for Reforming Universities and Public Schools by C. A. Bowers.
Fair Use Statement
About Buying Books Online

See Also --> Let Them Eat Data: How Computers Affect Education, Cultural Diversity, and the Prospects of Ecological Sustainability by C. A. Bowers

On This Page --> Review 1 - Review 2 - C. A. Bowers' Syllabus

Purhase Online

CLICK TO ORDER The Culture of Denial: Why the Environmental Movement Needs a Strategy for Reforming Universities and Public Schools by C. A. Bowers.

Book Review

Environmental crisis highlights the west's culture of denial

By Yusuf Progler

The recent protests at the World Trade Organization (WTO) meetings in Seattle have pushed environmental concerns into the public eye. US president Clinton and other members of the Úlite cadres of the WTO were forced to defend western economic practices and policies in ways that had not been planned. One issue that received a great deal of attention, from protesters and officials alike, was the impact of western economic policies on natural ecosystems. But most of the ensuing discussion treated environmental concerns in their political and economic dimensions, and in this sense both sides of the debate share a common set of core assumptions.

In the rarefied milieu of political and economic wrangling, with public relations and image-making concerns defining the terms of debate, deeper problems were obscured or distorted. But, proceeding from the assumption that the ecological crisis is at bottom a cultural crisis, some environmentalists and activists have challenged the very terms of the debate. In The Culture of Denial, C. A. Bowers asks hard questions about the nature of culture, and asserts that people living the modernist western lifestyle, and Americans in particular, are participating in a culture that is in denial about serious environmental issues. Bowers takes this argument even further by insisting that schools and universities perpetuate this culture of denial, and that implicitly "all education is environmental education."

Public schools and universities have not recognized that, by advancing a particular knowledge-system, they are actually sorting various bodies of knowledge into different qualitative categories. High status knowledge, according to Bowers, is that which is favored by the modernist educational system and is primarily concerned with technological progress and economic growth.

Low status knowledge, on the other hand, is generally excluded from view because it refers things that do not promote the modernist system. Many still-vibrant revealed religions and non-western traditional cultures, especially those that teach material constraint and living harmoniously within an ecosystem, are by definition low status in the modernist educational scheme.

Educational institutions reinforce the behavior that is pervasive in consumer society. Bowers discusses how the American corporate media also promote a message that equates 'modern' and 'progressive' with a consumer lifestyle and technological advancement. Media coverage of local knowledge schemes, especially those that have coherent and workable visions of ecologically sound living, is virtually non-existent. Bowers argues that many western-oriented societies share a conceptual matrix that denies the ecological impact of their cultural beliefs and practices, irrespective of the surface political debates that busy them. He argues that it is not only toxins and pollutants that destroy living ecosystems; the real culprits are western and modern values, beliefs and modes of behaviors.

With the advent of satellite television, western corporations and their local proxies are now able to advertise the modernist way of life to the whole world, or to those parts that can afford the equipment. This makes sense because western civilization has largely lost sight of its identity, and has come to rely on advertisement and fantasy-fulfilment to define what is important, and to create a sense of self and society. To the extent that people take this lifestyle for granted, corporate media images distort concepts of what is needed for a wholesome and fulfilling lifestyle.

At bottom, people need fresh air, clean water and healthy food, yet on the surface they think that they also need computers and automobiles. Bowers shows that this puts people into a 'double-bind' in which one set of needs causes problems with another set. Western consumer-culture is obsessed with fulfilling its glittering desires and wants, but disregards the ecological implications of its lifestyle. The necessary connections are obscured by western educational systems, which generally promote the assumptions and values of consumerism.

Bowers tries to show that western educational systems reinforce the cultural beliefs that contribute to environmental destruction. American public schools, for example, provide students with only the "romantic aspects of the ideology of modernism." Bowers shows that universities provide students with a narrow view of life, compartmentalized into various disciplines, that creates a sort of mythic ambiguity around modernist culture.

High-school students are primed to enter the world of high status knowledge because they receive a very limited knowledge base with which to make meaningful decisions. This creates a sort of class system that is less economic and more conceptual in nature, yet which keeps people focused on their own narrow economic interests by way of competitive job markets for high status knowledge. Someone receiving a university education is usually provided with nothing more than the tools and ideology to develop more efficient means with which to destroy the natural world, in the guise of economic progress and technological advancement.

Bowers challenges the high status, low content version of education promoted by western university systems, since they ignore the broader ecological implications of the knowledge-systems and cultural practices they promote. He argues instead for a more balanced approach to education, which would produce a culture of awareness about how society is dependent upon nature. In fact, Bowers seems to be calling for an overall more balanced way of life for westerners, and advocates a society in which people are aware of how they are affecting their environment and how their present practices restrict their options for the future.

Following discussions of technologies, in which he develops their cultural embeddedness, Bowers turns his attention to the role of language in reinforcing the culture of denial. He believes that language encodes reality into cultural beliefs, and that culture shapes every aspect of a people's thought and behavior. Accordingly, education can either reinforce or dismantle a cultural system by the language it uses. Western educational systems lack any sort of awareness of the cultural and linguistic basis of the ecological crisis, and promote instead a haphazard and absent-minded relationship with the environment. For Bowers, the key to solving the ecological crisis lies in reforming education, so he next turns his attention to the present day environmental movements in the west, focusing on what they can do about educational reform.

Reform efforts advanced by environmental groups have fallen short in understanding the total scope of the problems they claim to address. One difficulty, as Bowers points out, is in their tendency to fragment ecological diversity into specific political causes. While the environmental movement is made up of a wide range of interest groups, many of them deal only with specific environmental problems, and fail to consider how broader cultural assumptions are causal factors, and how these assumptions are perpetuated by education. Bowers believes that a major cause of this dysfunction is that environmentalists rely on many of the same modernist assumptions as those they claim to be fighting, especially regarding uses of science and technology. He insists that environmentalists develop broader, more coherent strategies for educating people on the implications of the ecological crisis.

To advocate environmental awareness seems passÚ nowadays. Even Al Gore, the American vice president, claims to be an environmentalist. Many corporations claim to have environmental policies, and advocate a program of 'wise use'. But these are nothing more than hegemonic co-optations of a problem that is ill-understood. Bowers goes a long way toward unpacking the problems with pseudo-environmental awareness; by identifying the ecological crisis as a cultural crisis, he challenges all those who claim to be environmentalists to rethink their basic cultural assumptions. For others, the book should be a wake-up call, a warning that western civilization is no longer viable; it ought also to give pause for reflection on tenable and sustainable alternatives.

Book Review

Reviewed for H-Teachpol by Eric Shibuya, [email protected]
Colorado State University

Published by H-Teachpol (June, 1998).

Chet Bowers puts forth a powerful argument. His critique extends not only to society's preoccupation with technology, "progress," and economic "growth," but also points to how our educational system has aided in instilling and reinforcing these values, from primary education to university levels. Bowers argues that the educational system needs to be completely restructured to instill values and teach practices that lead to ecologically sustainable forms of living. Along the way, Bowers points to how even thinkers considered "reformists" contribute to ecologically unsustainable ways of thinking. What is being called for here is not simply the addition of environmental studies programs, or the add-on of "green" courses into the curriculum, but rather a fundamental change in the foundations, the very values, that our educational system strives to propagate.

Bowers first discusses what he calls the "culture of denial," the refusal to examine the possibility that how we live our lives now may not be environmentally sustainable. The continuing obsession of consumerism and commercialism, the unquestioning faith in technological "fixes," and escapist practices via television or (more insidiously) the Internet; these practices all insure that the bulk of the population will not stop to question where we are going, what road we are traveling on. Rather than leading to questions of current practices, Bowers argues that our educational system has reinforced this culture of denial. It has done this by its presentation of history as linear, "progress" from traditional (bad) to "modern." Further, the educational system has focused upon the individual as an autonomous unit, and its insistence that knowledge and discovery comes from within the individual misses the point that every individual is in fact culturally, socially grounded. Finally, (and this is especially true at the higher levels of education), Bowers notes that "higher-level" knowledge is privileged, meaning that type of knowledge based on "rational" principles (e.g., the scientific method). Forms of knowledge that harken back to "tradition" are labeled as backward and not useful to our discussion; they do not "further knowledge." As such, even reform movements such as those advocated by Paulo Friere or the postmodern movement do not give us avenues of action that are environmentally sustainable. Postmodernism, for instance, while claiming to be a break from modernity, actually extends the modernity project in that postmodernism continues to view the individual as the basic unit of analysis, and to view past traditions and ways of life as backward. All of these values are so taken for granted that even these so-called reform movements are based somewhat on these foundations. Bowers' work seeks to undermine these values, to question their authority. Quite literally, a paradigm shift is in order.

All that being said, there are some shortcomings. First, and this is a minor quibble, Bowers notes that the modern mindset is instilled within children and a deeply unconscious level, and yet his focus here is to confront these values later in life, notably at the university level, at which point it may be too late. (Bowers does later discuss primary socialization, but this only briefly, and much later in the work). Also, Bowers notes that the cultural elite come from similar educational backgrounds, yet his focus here is on our public school system, then our universities. It may do well to point to how our elites are trained in our private school system, where certainly a different kind of socialization--that of class--is going on as well. There is also some cynicism as to how effective our basic educational system really is. Bowers notes, "most students graduate from high school with such a limited knowledge base that they are able to do little more than be compliant consumers and work in low-status jobs" (p. 38). This may be the case, but it is exactly at this level that the ecologically unsustainable practices have already been instilled within the individual. Also, while Bowers' criticism of emancipatory writers such as Paulo Friere does point to Friere's conceptualization of the individual as atomistic, it should be noted that Friere's work isn't focused upon the ecological ties between the individual and society, but rather the break from what Friere argues are constraints that are unnecessary. (And even Bowers notes [p. 10] that some traditional forms of living should be put aside.) In contrast, Bowers' work here focuses upon the ecological limits that need to be placed on any form of human emancipation. To therefore argue that Friere and others that follow him miss the point that emancipation does have its limits may go too far.

Next, Bowers often uses the term "tradition" rather loosely. At times it means those patterns of thinking which lead to environmentally sustainable ways of life, but at others Bowers discusses the modern mindset as being instilled as "traditional," and also points out that there are some traditions which are not ecologically friendly. (This is an ironic point: Bowers argues, quite rightly, that those traditions which are not ecologically friendly need to be discarded. But, isn't the discarding of "nonuseful" traditions symbolic of modernity?) Also, part of Bowers' discussion of tradition seems to place tradition as something that isn't fluid, when in fact his conceptualization of the modern mindset and its extension into postmodernism shows very well how "traditions" can change and metamorphisize. It is only much later in the work (p. 168 ff.) that Bowers acknowledges the fluidity of tradition, at which point the reader may be somewhat frustrated by the term.

The final shortcoming is that while Bowers touches upon the internationalization of the mindset of modernity, there is very little discussion as to the power and influence of the international system, or the power of the state in maintaining the modern mindset. There is a recognition that those in power, such as university administrators, will feel threatened at a movement that undermines "high status" knowledge, but this recognition doesn't go further, notably to government officials (who make the funding decisions for public schools and universities), and multinational capital (who donate huge funds to universities). Bowers recognizes and accurately points to the individual as being culturally and socially based, but makes little mention until much later in the book of how the "inertia of history," to borrow from Foucault, makes social change truly difficult.

Culture of Denial is a powerful, controversial book. It will stimulate discussion in a course not only in environmental politics or environmental education, but would be an effective addition even in a wider course on pedagogy, as it will force both students and instructors to examine what it is that they are teaching (and learning) beyond what is made explicit. Some final words of warning, however. This is not an easily accessible book, which is most unfortunate, as this book deserves a wider audience that it will probably receive. Culture of Denial can be a hard read, and there is little doubt that its content will be resisted by most students, if not by some academics. Bowers is quite clear in his presentation, that the ecological crisis has reached a point where it may no longer be viable to consider "academic freedom" as an unqualified good. "The modern understanding of academic freedom must now be reconstituted in ways that foreground human dependency on increasingly distressed ecosystems" (p. 202). There will also no doubt come the claim that what Bowers is advocating is not education per se, but indoctrination. Of this point, the entire argument presented in Culture of Denial is that our educational system as it stands indoctrinates students into a mindset that is not ecologically viable in the long term. As such, the accusation that this is an indoctrinating program is only damning if one denies the current indoctrination of taken-for-granted values within our school system. All in all, this is a powerful work, and if both students and instructors are willing to work through it, it will provide a strong learning experience and a challenge to previously taken-for-granted understandings.

C. A. Bower's Syllabus
University of Oregon

ENVS 410/510
Computers, Globalization and the Ecological Crisis
Winter 1998
Time: UH 14:00-15:20

Instructor: Chet Bowers

Description of Course: The course will examine a number of questions that arise from the increasing world-wide use of computers. As many of the beneficial uses of computers are already recognized, the questions are framed in ways that bring out the cultural mediating characteristics that are not usually considered. the questions include: What are the differences between the culture of cyberspace and the culture of everyday life? How do the values, experience of time, and form of individual subjectivity reinforced in cyberspace differ from the diverse cultural patterns found in more ecologically centered cultures? What are the differences between local knowledge and computer mediated data and information? What are the implications of embedding the justification of globalizing computer in the scientific theory of evolution? what are the differences between an electronic community and real life communities (in the dominant and traditional cultures)? How do computers contribute to the commodification of knowledge and relationships? do computers reinforce a particular idological/epistemological orientation? Is data really the basis of thought or is thought influenced by the metaphorical language of a cultural group?

The readings and class discussions will provide a more complex understanding of the double binds that surround the use of computers--particularly for people who consider themselves to be environmentalists. Hopefully, the course will lead to a more critical and culturally sensitive understanding of the role that computers play in globalizing the patterns of thinking and communicating that are contributing to an ecological crisis.

Readings (selections from the following):
Sherry Turkle, Life on the Screen: Identity in the Age of the Internet
Nicholas Negroponte, Being Digital
Hans Moravec, Mind Children: The Future of Robot and Human Intelligence
Kevin Kelly, Out of Control: The Rise of Neo-Biological Civilization
Gregory Stock, Metaman: The Merging of Humans and Machines into a Global Superorganism
Howard Rheingold, Virtual Reality
Theodore Roszak, The Cult of Information
Wolfgang Sachs, The Development Dictionary: A Guide to Knowledge as Power
Frederique A. Marglin and Stephen Marglin (editors), Dominating Knowledge: Development, Culture, and Resistance and Decolonizing Knowledge: From Development to Dialogue
C.A. bowers, The Culture of Denial: Why the Environmental Movement Needs a Strategy for Reforming Universities and Public Schools and chapters from book manuscript "Let Them Eat Data: The Ecological and Educational Consequences of Globalizing Computer Culture"
Keith Basso, Wisdom Sits in Places: Language and Landscape Among the Western Apache
Jerry Mander and Edward Goldsmith, The Case Against the Global Economy and the Local
Sim Van der Ryn and Stuart Cowan, Ecological Design

Purchase Online

See Also --> Let Them Eat Data: How Computers Affect Education, Cultural Diversity, and the Prospects of Ecological Sustainability by C. A. Bowers

About Buying Books Online

Didn't find what you are looking for? We've been online since 1996 and have created 1000's of pages. Search below and you may find just what you are looking for.

Michael R. Meuser
Data Research & GIS Specialist is an independent firm specializing in GIS project development and data research. We created the first U.S. based interactive toxic chemical facility maps on the internet in 1996 and we have been online ever since. Learn more about us and our services.

Have a project in mind? If you have data, GIS project or custom shapefile needs contact Mike.

Contact Us

Report Broken Links

Subscribe for Updates

Follow on Facebook
News & Updates

Find: Maps, Shapefiles, GIS Software & More

MapCruzin Blog for updates, questions and answers
Blog Updates

More Blog Updates


Google Earth Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) Maps
Lester Brown's Plan B 3.0
State GIS Shapefiles, Maps & Resources
GIS Shapefiles & Maps
GIS Programs, Tools & Resources
Free World Country & Regional Maps
GIS / GPS Careers and Job Positions
Disease Outbreak Maps
Extreme Weather & Disaster Maps
Free World Maps from the CIA Factbook
Arctic National Wildlife Refuge ANWR Maps
Oil and Gas Maps
Africanized Honey Bees
Renewable Energy Potential Maps of the United States
Terrorism Maps
War Maps
Google Maps
Weather Maps
GPS Resources
Historical Maps of the World
Google Earth
Library of Congress American Memory Map Downloads
Toxic Chemical Pollution Maps
Climate Change Maps
Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) Maps
Census Shapefiles
World Maps


Environmental Justice
Data Sources
Greenwash & JunkScience
Statistical Resources
Wireless Dangers
Surviving Climate Change
Global Right-To-Know
Creating Living Economies
Books of Note
Toxic Klamath River
Federal Lands Maps
TRI Analysis
TRI Webmaps
EnviroRisk Map Network
Community-Based Research
Right-To-Know or Left to Wonder?
Chemical Industry Archives
21st Century Warfare
National Parks and Public Lands
Trade Secrets/Toxic Deception
GIS Books
Our Projects
Other Projects
1999 Archive Environews
Environmental Books
Environmental Links
Redwood Coast Information
Recycle, Salvage, Reuse

Shapefile Store
Free GIS Software
Free Map Downloads
Free Shapefiles
Free Remote Sensing
Free Topo Maps
Free GIS Tutorial
Free GPS

About MapCruzin - Cookies, Privacy, Fair Use and Disclaimer - Advertise on

Copyright © 1996 - 2019 Michael Meuser, All Rights Reserved
MapCruzin is a Pop-Up Free Website -- Best Viewed With ANY Browser